"Valley Winter Song," Fountains of Wayne (S-Curve)

This one kind of treads the line as to whether it's really a Christmas song, but the chorus is irresistible and it's more holiday-oriented to my ears than "My Favorite Things," so a Christmas song it is. We've celebrated many relationship songs here in which the Christmas reference is secondary, so this could go along with those. The Waynes are already on record with "I Want an Alien for Christmas," a more overt and fun holiday song, and this is from their 2003 album Welcome Interstate Travelers, which also includes their big hit "Stacy's Mom."